Just as there is a dark side to transformational leadership where leaders use their abilities to inspire and lead followers to destructive, selfish, and potentially evil ends tourish, 20. The dark side of transformational leadership challenges this prevailing belief and critiques theories of transformational leadership. Tourish argues that the orthodoxy assumes that all leaders actions are inherently rational, and does not recognize that unquestioning conformity to the coercive controls of some powerhungry senior executives. Regarding non transformational leadership, five categories emerged. Written in a lively and engaging style, the book uses a number of case studies to. Leader development and the dark side of personality. As posited by burns, transactional leadership can be seen as the counter to transformational leadership. This paper will explain the transformational leadership approach by discussing its components, factors, strengths, weaknesses, and steps for application. In a world of fad leadership, bookofthemonth, and ceo biographies it seems the transformational leadership tl model provides an intuitive framework that separates scholarship from anecdotal advice. Since transformational leadership is a combination of several leadership models, it is more complicated to understand the concept and teach. Second, traits do a better job predicting the emergence of leaders and the appearance of leadership than actually distinguishing between. It is also important to point out that all types of leadership have a dark side when an abuse of power is realized. The definition of dark side of leadership in current literature is unclear.
Hannahb a university of nebraska, lincoln, usa b center. Justification and critisism of transformational leadership. The leader, whether in business, politics or any other field is the most important. The goal of charismatic leadership is to have followers react in certain ways. For him, transformational leadership is a flawless, perfect and idealised form of leadership. Transformational leadership, organizational culture, and. Transformational leadersbeware of the dark side the. In response to critics discussing the dark sides of transformational leaders, bass differentiates between transformational leadership and pseudotransformational leadership. Some so called leaders learn how to manage perception through transformational leadership practices in order to mask dark side character traits.
Transformational leadership has positive effects on employee. Brad jackson, fletcher building education trust chair in leadership, university of auckland business school, australia at last, an erudite and critical analysis of transformational leadership that explores the dark side and pulls back the selfimposed curtains that are so frequently an element of this approach. Clipping is a handy way to collect important slides you want to go back to later. In the section below, literature on tl and the dark side of leadership will be discussed. Transformational leaders seek to unite employees and encourage them to make the organizations vision a reality bryman, 1992. Conversely, employees who feel pressured by others to do more or have limited control over their work environment. It can be seen from the initial correlations that transformational leadership total scores were negatively related with cautious and reserved hds scores, and positively related with colorful scores. Part 2 traces the different types of dark side leaders. Jan 01, 20 the dark side of transformational leadership book. What personal issues may plague people in their exercise of leadership. This may be true to some firms functioning only in a market with stable technology, workforce, and environment. Part 1 details how the dark side can selfdestruct ones leadership. Book essay on the dark side of transformational leadership.
Among these, destructive leadership that includes authoritarian elements was identified as the most frequently mentioned form of nontransformational leadership. Most articles were printed, but some were published in electronic format and do not have page numbers. Now customize the name of a clipboard to store your clips. This master dissertation therefore aims to shed new light. Criticisms and arguments against transformational leadership. The dark side of transformational leadership workcare. This new paradigm described the leader and follower interaction as a mutually elevating process which bernard bass later described as. Given that we were interested in the withinperson effects of transformational leader. Pellegrini, ek, scandura, ta 2006 leadermember exchange lmx, paternalism and delegation in the turkish business culture. Rode, 2010 between transformational leadership and followers creativity. Keith grint, warwick business school, warwick university, uk. Volunteering time and expertise to help others is connected to an improved sense of personal autonomy and wellbeing.
This research is centered on a particular model of leadership, transformational leadership, which formerly was not conceptualized for the school system. Adopting the transformational leadership perspective in a. A common feature of modern perceptions of leadership is that leadership is a good and positive thing. Overcoming the dark side of leadership lead with grace. At last, an erudite and critical analysis of transformational leadership that explores the dark side and pulls back the selfimposed curtains that are so frequently an element of this approach. The dark side of transformational leadership confronts this orthodoxy by illustrating how such approaches can encourage narcissism, megalomania and poor decisionmaking on the part of leaders, at great expense to those organizations they are there to serve. Apr 20, 20 the dark side of transformational leadership confronts this orthodoxy by illustrating how such approaches can encourage narcissism, megalomania and poor decisionmaking on the part of leaders, at great expense to those organizations they are there to serve. The dark side of transformational leader behaviors for leader themselves. In order to contribute to the body of empirical research on transformational leadership and individual creativity and to help address the issue of a confusing pattern of results, we argue that negative side effects of transformational leadership. Western michigan university, 1992 transformational leadership was introduced by james macgregor bums in 1978. This new paradigm described the leader and follower interaction as a mutually elevating process which bernard bass later described as performance. More specifically, building on the insights of the previous chapter, in this.
Often the dark side can be unknown to the leader and can show up in bizarre manners. Transformational leadership and organizational change. The bright and dark sides of leadership sage journals. The dark side of transformational leadership confronts this orthodoxy by illustrating how. The leader, whether in business, politics or any other field, is the most important factor in determining whether organizations succeed or fail. A transformational leadership score was based on qualities such as leading by example, making employees feel they are contributing to a common goal, providing intellectual stimulation, and giving. Pdf the dark side of transformational leader behaviors. Transformational leadership has positive effects on. Transformational and transactional leadership, which focus on the relationship between leaders and employees, are the most recent development of leadership theories. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Request pdf the dark side of transformational leadership.
Hannahb a university of nebraska, lincoln, usa b center for the army profession and ethic, west point. Transformational leaders inspire followers to accomplish more by concentrating on the followers values. The hitler problem, for instance, is often debated in the leadership literature and critics of transformational leadership contend that hitler was a transformational. The dark side of transformational leadership is a singularly strong contribution to leadership theory and practice.
In light of the growing interest in the dark side of organizations in mainstream research, two concepts related to organizational behavior and management literature have received attention in. Pdf the dark side of transformational leader behaviors for leader. In this particular essay, the main focus will be on the transformational leadership and some of the arguments and criticisms against it, as well as some counter arguments in favor of the transformational leadership. Penn state, 2015 when we are talking about the dark side of charismatic leadership, this type of follower can be dangerous to themselves or others. The influence of gender and culture on leadership styles of smes in china and sweden. The use of charisma paired with narcissism or other dark side trait can be used to manipulate and can lead to unethical treatment psu wc 2015. The dark side of transformational leadership a critical. It is called so because of its ability to mimic much of the same tools and trades of the true transformational model while imposing negative rather than positive imagery and messaging to influence behavior.
A critical perspective, routledge, 20 find, read and cite all the research you need on. Oct 28, 2015 some so called leaders learn how to manage perception through transformational leadership practices in order to mask dark side character traits. The dark side of leadership and silence in the workplace. Most articles were printed, but some were published in electronic format. We pivot from this predominant focus to a focus on the detriments of transformational leader behaviors for leaders themselves. Transformational leadersbeware of the dark side the bailey. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. In the dark side of transformational leadership, tourish applies a variety of social psychological theories to analyze how and why the coercive leadership style. This is an uncomfortable but very important mustread for all students of leadership. The dark side of transformational leader behaviors for leaders. Nevertheless, some people argue that transformational leadership is unnecessary as transactional leadership can be effective enough to deal with problems. Regarding nontransformational leadership, five categories emerged. So if there is a dark side of charismatic leaders and charisma is a key characteristic of a transformational leader, then there is surely a dark side of transformational leaders.
Rima every leader suffers from some degree of personal dysfunction. A paradox of sorts existed in the lives of most of the leaders who had experienced. Development and learning in organizations, volume 28, issue 1 dennis tourish, routledge, hove, 20, isbn. Examining core selfevaluations, narcissism, transformational leadership, and strategic influence. The dark side of transformational leader behaviors for. The 1990s became the era of new leadership model, the era in which charismatic and. The spring edition of workcares quarterly newsletter, vitality atlas, examines the employee health and business benefits of volunteerism. The brightside and the darkside of ceo personality. Traditionally, a transformational leader has been synonymous with a charismatic leader. Yet studies on the impact of gender and culture on transformational and transactional leadership styles are limited. Leadership remains somewhat of a contested concept about which there remains no universal definition or consensus about what it actually is. Instead, they describe a future theyd like to create instead.
The problem with charismatic leadership comes when that leader has other traits or characteristics that can pair with their charisma to have a dark side. Arguments against transformational leadership theory. What are the causes, results, potential prevention of the many failures of leaders. Aug 16, 2016 transformational leaders dont start by denying the world around them.
Jul 16, 2017 this form of negativelyimagined influential leadership is called pseudo transformational leadership. A critical perspective kindle edition by tourish, dennis. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading the dark side of transformational leadership. Transformational leadership is a process of transforming the organizational behavior, the culture.
It focuses on a leaders ability to inspire followers and it does so by focusing on a vision that can change the structures around the organization. First, contrary to what we believed 20 years ago, we can say that traits can predict leadership. Jul 20, 2016 overcoming the dark side of leadership gary l. In a transformational leadership, the leader is considered as a visionary idol and the leader involve in. Transformational leadership, and provides an illustration of the various ways transformational leadership can be applied. Basss writing highlights a strong heroic bias in transformational leadership. Leader development and the dark side of personality p. Jul 01, 20 a transformational leadership style, which conveys a sense of trust and meaningfulness and individually challenges and develops employees, could lead to greater employee wellbeing, according to. A conservation of resources perspective article pdf available in the academy of management journal october 2018 with. Concluding with a new approach that offers an alternative to the dominant transformational model, the dark side of transformational leadership will be an invaluable text for academics interested in leadership, students on leadership courses requiring a more critical perspective, and anyone concerned with how people lead people, and the lessons. The theories of transformational leadership discuss and suggest the importance of transformational leaders in the organizations for sustainable growth. Dec 15, 2011 overcoming the dark side of leadership 1.
Most research into leadership has presented leaders as heroic, charismatic and transformational visionaries. A conservation of resources perspective abstract the vast majority of theory and research to date on transformational leadership has focused on how transformational leader behaviors influence followers, portraying those behaviors as unequivocally beneficial. Transformational leadership transformational leadership, developed by bass and avolio 1995 through a multifactor leadership model mlq, has four components. Given that we were interested in the within person effects of transformational leader. Seth godin transformational leadership is among the more recent leadership theories. Overcoming the dark side of leadership presentation summarizing parts of the book by gary l.
The book hits directly at the heart of much of what is going awry in the corporate. This form of negativelyimagined influential leadership is called pseudotransformational leadership. The focus here, as the title clearly indicates, is on the problematic values, assumptions and. Apr 26, 20 buy the dark side of transformational leadership.
1470 992 327 1323 528 773 1239 695 1368 117 1098 915 338 246 461 510 434 1409 763 122 1411 1540 655 440 852 267 1301 379 650 1067 187 1350 953 1195 553 746 1099 411 483 1179 161 232